Journal

Journal

Evidence is not proof

A hundred years since Earhart vanished. I said no to the headline.

Amelia Earhart and Fred Noonan disappeared on 2 July 1937, trying to reach Howland Island. One theory says they landed on Nikumaroro and lived for a time as castaways. People have searched the island for decades.

A television company paid for us to survey the reef edge this year, the centenary. Under the 2001 UNESCO underwater heritage convention, wrecks become ‘underwater cultural heritage’ after a hundred years. The aircraft, if it’s there, now counts.

We found a corroded metal fragment and a section of what might be a 1930s shoe sole. We recorded both in place and left them for the Kiribati authorities, as our permit required.

The producer wanted me to say on camera that we’d found her. I said that we’d found something consistent with several stories, including hers.

They cut my line. The documentary did well anyway. I’m told that’s how television works. I’ll keep the answer that’s true.

Record it first. Report it.
Never sell it.

Follow the field journal as it happens, in Heath's own words.

Read the journal